Viral Chicago Food

-Grubbing in Chicago
Five of a Kind: Gone Viral

I started to do these five of a kind posts as a way to showcase specific dishes. It’s much easier writing a paragraph on a piece of pizza I tried than it is doing an entire post. It’s also a way to get a little more content up and not left on my phone to forget about. So I’m always thinking of ways I can combine five different things I ate and this post kind of came about when I recently tried two places I knew of due to their popularity on social media apps like Instagram. I thought to myself hmm what other things did I eat that were directly influenced by Instagram and I was able to come up with five spots (and dishes) that I likely learned of online by appearing on my food dominant timelines. So today’s post is about five places that have gone viral. It’s true that a lot of viral foods are gimmicks but not all of them are. Some are just good and catch on in a way that’s organic in terms of specific dishes like pizza, bagels, burgers, pasta, and hand rolls being popular with the younger TikTok demographic. 

__________________________________________________

Tilly Bagel (South Loop)

We start with bagels but not at the spot in Lincoln Park that had lines around the block last week. I don’t have plans to go there as I already tried an outlet in Delray Beach and the bagels there reminded me of the packaged ones you get at the supermarket. Today we check out Tilly Bagel which was a popup during the pandemic that turned brick and mortar in 2023. Tilly is known for its sourdough bagels that people have been known to line up for. No lines when I visited on a Tuesday morning (St. Patrick's Day) to try their popular cacio e pepe bagel with a smear of caramelized onion cream cheese. Simply put I’m not a big bagel guy so make of this what you will. I thought it was ok. The bagel had decent chew but maybe needed a little more. The cream cheese didn't really have much of a grilled onion taste and I thought there was too much of it on mine but I’ve seen people complain at places that put much less so maybe overloaded is the preferred normal for most but not for me. In the end I felt about these how I do about most bagels - it was fine for what it was - a bagel.

Cacio e Pepe Bagel with Caramelized Onion Cream Cheese at Tilly Bagel
__________________________________________________

Chomp Pizza (Pilsen)

Next up we head over to Pilsen where we’ll pop into the 18th Street Pink Line stop where Chomp Pizza runs a slice stand. It’s ran by a guy named Travis who used to worked at Paulie Gee’s in Wicker Park before doing his own thing at Chomp Pizza where they pretty much serve just one thing - a slice of cheese pizza ($5). I saw this place making the rounds online and made a point of trying it. I arrived right around opening time so the pizza had just come out of the oven. The pizza is made with a simple blend of tomatoes, Grande Cheese Co. mozzarella and some oregano but the magic is in the dough which is taken very seriously. The color on the crust is slightly darker and the texture is crisp and crackly. I can see why this place has become popular with people passing thru the 18th St. Station. 

Cheese Slice at Chomp Pizza
__________________________________________________

Smash Jibarito (Humboldt Park)

A lot of these viral food spots started as pop-ups as is the case with our next stop - Smash Jibarito in Humboldt Park. These guys paid their dues on the pop-up circuit and now have a spiffy new brick & mortar on Division. It’s the perfect fit for their hit smash burgers inspired by the classic Jibarito sandwiches that originated in this Puerto Rican enclave. This means instead of buns they’re using flattened and fried green plantains aka tostones to hold their smashed beef patties. The menu is tight with just a few burgers, some sides, and one wildcard item which is their twist on a pizza puff. The plantain “bun” on these burgers holds up better than you’d think and adds some extra crunch to the mix. Pictured below is “estilo Animal” aka Animal Style ala In-N-Out and it's a damn good burger. 

Jibarito Smash Burger at Smash Jibarito
__________________________________________________



Italian Homemade Co. (Fulton Market)

Pasta is a dish that tends to go viral as often as any and Fulton Market is a place where restaurants commonly go viral so of course a pasta spot on Fulton Market is going to go viral. The Italian Homemade Company got started in San Francisco circa 2014 before opening their Chicago location around 2024 as made from scratch pasta spots have really taken off. As soon as you walk in you’ll see the setup they have for making pasta from scratch plus a fridge with a bunch of that pasta packaged for home use. Or if you want to eat there you can pick a pasta and pick a sauce to go with it or choose one of their specialty pastas. Seems like most of the people working here are Italian, for whatever that’s worth. I saw some videos about the lasagna and they list it among their specialties so I stopped in with a friend when he said he had a taste for lasagna. There was some sort of meet and greet going on so the place was packed and our table was surrounded by annoying people with no sense of their surroundings and it was loud but that's to be expected in this area. I got the meat lasagna which is made with a beef and pork bolognese, bechamel, parmigiano. This was a textbook version. The pasta was fresh and soft and the meat sauce had a nice beefy taste to it. A very hearty dish. I wouldn’t go out of my way to eat here but if you're already near there it’s a pretty good option. 

Meat Lasagna at Homemade Italian Company
__________________________________________________

Noriko Handroll Bar (West Loop)

Last stop takes us over to Perilla Korean Fare in the West Loop. Perilla is a Michelin-recognized Korean BBQ restaurant group with a Steakhouse in the Loop. They also have a tiny handroll bar located in the basement of their West Loop location. It’s called Noriko Handroll Bar and it’s a hot reservation in big part due to it being such a small space with seating for around 20. The menu is revolved around handrolls with starters and a few crudo options. They have a few different sets you can get that mixes and matches a variety of rolls. Every seat is at the chef’s counter and all handrolls are made to order and meant to be eaten immediately. We started with a couple crudos which were just ok. I chose to go with the chefs handroll set with yellowtail, California roll, bluefin tuna poke, bluefin tuna toro, and bay scallop dynamite. I think I paid around $42 for the five rolls. They were all pretty good but the bay scallop dynamite roll was perfectly named as it was a lot more dynamic than the others as far as flavor. It’s described as a baked/spicy scallop with toppings like masago and sweet soy and it gets a kiss of flame with a blowtorch that gives it a smokiness that almost resembles a hot dog. That might sound funny but this was a really satisfying taste to me and one of the best things I ate last year. If I ever go back I’ll probably order a few of those and make a meal out of them.

Bay Scallop Dynamite Roll at Noriko Handroll Bar
__________________________________________________

See ya next time @chibbqking

Creepies

-Grubbing in Chicago
A Neo-Bistro in the West Loop

Creepies has been one of the more worthy buzzed about spots on Randolph’s “Restaurant Row.” The neo-bistro from chefs David and Anna Posey was recently named the best new restaurant in Chicago by John Kessler at Chicago Magazine. The culinary power couple opened Creepies next door to Elske, their flagship restaurant in August of 2025. I've stopped in twice since they opened their doors.

Recently Opened in West Loop

For those wondering about the interesting name it came about as an inside joke between owners David Posey and his wife Anna who came up with it while scouting locations, many of which came off as creepy. They joked about naming their project Creepies and it just kind of stuck. But it fits the space which is a small and eclectic spot with dark and dim lighting and a slightly offbeat European-inspired aesthetic. As far as the food goes it was described by John Kessler as “Parisian-style neo-bistro showcasing distinctive recipes with a deep sense of place. That place would be the Midwest.” 

Lyonnaise salad

Our first visit came about a month after they first opened. Not too long after they introduced lunch. We recently stopped in to see what was up during the daytime. The lunch menu is small but sturdy with 14 dishes total. For starters we tried the Lyonnaise salad with smoked maitakes substituting for traditional pork lardons. This was a nice touch turning Lyon France’s iconic salad into a completely meat free dish. The egg was cooked to the perfect temperature to where it was runny but warm. I can usually gauge a kitchen by the salads and this was a signal that more good things were coming. The lunch menu features two sandwiches and they both caught my eye. They have a croque monsieur with ham and mornay and a Niçoise sandwich with smoked beets. It was a nice and somewhat humid day on our visit so the Niçoise sandwich was my pick and I think I made the right call though we won’t know for sure until I try the croque monsieur. That said the Niçoise is going to be tough to top as this was one of the best sandwiches I’ve ate in a long time. If I hadn’t known it was completely vegetarian I would’ve assumed there was tuna in the style of the French Riviera’s signature salad. The sandwich consisted of three layers starting with smoked beets on the bottom and chopped Niçoise olives on top with a bunch of fresh crunchy greens in between. They really nailed the fresh and briny flavors but a sandwich can only be as good as the bread and the sturdy sesame seeded bread from Publican was outstanding at holding it all together. This just might be the best veggie sandwich around right now. 

Niçoise Sandwich at Creepies

Next up was a surprise gift from the kitchen in the form of a freekeh crepe with artichoke, spring onion, and fromage blanc. I had to look up what freekeh was and it’s a roasted grain made of young green durum wheat that originated in the ancient cuisines of Egypt, Jordan, Lebanon, and Syria. The Freekeh crepe at Creepies is a textural masterpiece that crackles when cut into. I loved the mix of ingredients inside as this dish had a very distinct Parisian taste. It was pretty great. They seem to be using the crepe as a way to showcase seasonal flavors so I’ll be keeping my eye on what’s next. 

freekeh crepe with artichoke, spring onion, and fromage blanc

The menu is seasonal so a few of the dishes we ate in September are gone but I hope the tomato dish we had makes a comeback as it was the best use of the late summer tomato bounty I tried in 2025. I forgot to take a pic of the menu so I forget exact details but the pairing of fresh and in-season tomatoes and peaches sitting atop a pile of creamy lebnah was the perfect combo of salty and sweet. Whether it’s here or next door at Elske the vegetable dishes shine. The “Tarte Flambé, Tavern Style” is another example of the kitchens ability to make great food without meat. This seems to be one of their signature dishes as it’s been on the menu since day one. The kitchens spin on the Alsatian flatbread in the style of a tavern thin pizza is topped with fromage blanc, oyster mushrooms, onion and chives. The crisp and cracker like texture works in unison with a creamy set of toppings. 

Tomato, Peaches, Labneh

Tarte Flambé, Tavern Style

On our visit last September they had a seasonal corn crepe that I thought was wonderful at capturing the sweet and milky flavor of the end of the summer treat. We’ll always try the fries so long as they’re not from Sysco meaning they make them on site and as expected the fries here are fantastic. Each and every one was golden on the outside and creamy with a deep potato taste. They do a two step process as far as the frying goes using both clarified butter and rice bran oil. The former adds great flavor while the latter makes them extra crispy. These are easily some of the best fries in the city. 

Summer Corn Crepe with Succotash and Green Tomato

French Fries at Creepies


Parisian Gnocchi with Ham, Gruyere, Egg Yolk

Roast chicken is supposed to be excellent here but I decided to pass on that due to the fact that every time I try a hyped up roast chicken dish it’s a bit of a letdown. I much prefer grilled chicken. So instead I decided to try the Parisian gnocchi made with Swiss, ham, and egg yolk. It comes with a large Parmesan crisp on top making it about as rich of a dish as I’ve had in a long time. The gnocchi was light and delicate while the toppings were extremely creamy with a nice punch of saltiness from the ham. Erica got a fish dish that was a bit of a letdown in that it was just a piece of fish topped with endives. It was lacking in terms of creativity and also in presentation but it was still a perfectly fine dish, just not to the level of others. You can’t skip dessert here (or Elske) because Chef Anna Posey makes some of the best anywhere. I know a guy that goes to Elske once a year and orders every single desert as a full meal. They’re that good. We tried the baguette soft serve with chocolate and brown butter crumbs and it’s one of the better soft serve variations around town right now. Hats off to owners David and Anna Posey as well as Chef de Cuisine Tayler Ploshehanski for gifting us with this wonderful restaurant. It’s refreshing to have a spot of this caliber that doesn’t take itself too seriously. 

actual baguette flavor, topped with chocolate and brown butter crumbs

Creepies
1360 W Randolph St
Chicago, IL 60607
(312) 579-2727
Website

Bennigan's

-Grubbing in Chicago(land)
The Last Bennigan's in Illinois

I recently got the taste for a Monte Cristo which is weird because it’s not a sandwich I seek out in any sort of way. Except for recently when I used a pickup at O’Hare I had to do as an excuse to leave early and ride further west into Elgin where the only Bennigan’s left in the state Illinois of resides. 

Locals Favorite in Elgin

For those too young to remember eating at a Bennigan’s it’s a casual dining chain that peaked in the U.S. in the 1980s and 1990s after being founded in Atlanta Georgia back in 1976. Not coincidentally by the same guy who helped build brands like Chili’s and Steak & Ale. At its peak there were 1000’s of outlets but today there’s just 21 left in the U.S including this one found on the outskirts of Elgin. You walk in and it’s like stepping back into time. The entire place is carpeted and outdated TV’s are pinned into the walls while Billy Joel and Chicago (the band) and other 70’s and 80’s artists play on the speakers. As the sign out front says Bennigan’s serves American fare with Irish hospitality. There’s nothing Irish about the menu unless I guess you count the fish and chips or maybe the fact that potatoes are served in a handful of ways including potato skins which are straight out of 80’s. 

Monte Cristo at Bennigan's

Bennigan’s didn’t create the Monte Cristo but it’s a big reason why many Americans know of this sandwich said to be an adaptation of the French croque-monsieur, versions of it appeared in U.S. cookbooks as early as the 1930’s. Bennigan’s popularized a very specific and very over-the-top version that went onto become iconic. It starts with honey wheat bread with ham and turkey plus Swiss and American cheese all stacked in a sandwich that’s battered and deep-fried making it more like a savory pastry than a pan grilled sandwich. It’s finished with a dusting of powdered sugar and served with raspberry preserves for dipping. I recall having this sandwich once when we were on a roadtrip somewhere. I remember it was a real vibe inside and I also liked the baked potato soup. So on this visit some 30 years later I started with exactly that. Pro-tip: you can get half a sandwich (which is really one full sandwich) plus your choice of soup for $16. The baked potato soup which was more like gravy - not what I remembered. That said the sandwich was pretty good. I was impressed by the frying job as it was extra crisp without any trace of oil. I’m not big on mixing sweet with savory but it all works well together. I wouldn't eat this regularly but I would get it again if the opportunity came about.

Monte Cristo Closeup

I'd like to know the whole story behind this place because the food seems pretty good but it’s also in a random location connected to a Holiday Inn which seems fitting. I checked the Google reviews and "fish fry" was one of the most common mentions. I was intrigued considering how well the sandwich had been fried. I asked about it and was told it’s the same thing as their fish and chips but on Fridays it’s all you can eat. I said what the heck and put in an order. Not bad. Far from the best version I’ve tried but the batter was crisp and the cod meat inside was a delicate counter to the crunchy batter. It sounds funny to say but if you find yourself out this way you can do worse as far as far as chain food and other watering holes goes. After eating I took a seat at the bar and got a beer and the bartender noted their glasses were bigger than a typical pint. On top of that the beer was ice cold. That was fun. 

Fish and Chips at Bennigan's

Bennigan's
495 Airport Rd
Elgin, IL 60123
(847) 488-9900
Website